21 May How to Grow a Longer Nose
I lied. I flat out lied and it was so effortless I was shocked to hear the words slip so easily out of my mouth.
I am never fully awake when we ride the morning Metro. I’m not sleepy, though I’m in some closely associated world. I’m coherent enough to be a good parent to my accompanying little girl and be engaging and interactive with her early morning banter. But it takes a good amount of effort to maintain my equilibrium. Coffee is not a sufficient antidote for this condition.
So when a woman we’ve seen at the subway elevator a few times smiled at us I smiled back, easily and without concern. All my instruments were in the green: everything was within tolerance levels. She asked how we were doing and I replied. “Fine” is an answer I don’t have to think about. Then, without warning, she asked me where I work. This was the antidote. I suppose our morning “meetings” made her feel familiar enough with us to broach the subject.
Riding public transportation (along with surfing the net) has forced me to constantly evaluate my and my family’s sphere of privacy. It’s an odd mix and the boundaries are in constant flux. There is no doubt we are on display on our daily commutes. I’ve likened it to being in a play on stage. To ignore or deny that seems unreasonable. Children are a natural attraction in a world where we’ve come to question everyone around us. But there are limits and dealing with the fuzziness of those boundaries is not easy so early in the day.
Just this morning, when boarding the packed subway elevator, a older man queried my daughter: “What’s your name dear?” My daughter looked down silently. “Can she hear me?” he asked, turning to me. “Yes,” I replied. “But we’re teaching her not to talk to strangers.” All eyes or ears were on us. The spotlight was too bright. So he asked me her name. I had to tell him I didn’t feel comfortable divulging that information. I’m protective of both my and my family’s personal information. But the path of least resistance would have been simply to provide him with the information he requested. Often I am required to take the rougher road. And I need to be in full possession of my faculties in order to do that.
Within the boundaries, I’ve got to say, we are one of the Metro’s best entertainment venues. DC’s subway is relatively tame compared to other cities’s. There are no platform musicians and no one walking from car to car asking you for anything. So we are often the only entertainers aboard. Watching us play is a viable alternative to hiding behind the local news.
But like any production, the interaction is usually only between actors. Audience participation is limited. We do, on occasion, invite selected individuals to join us. Sometimes simple eye contact insures one a good time. While at others the unfolding play between my daughter and I requires additional participation.
Last week, as we were commuting home after a long day, I told her that mommy wouldn’t be home and I would be her chef for the evening. I’ve learned it’s always a good idea to prepare a four year old for out-of-the-ordinary events. And this was one of them. She knew an opening when she saw one. “I want candy for dinner!” she countered. “No, chicken nuggets tonight” (her main food group). “Candy.” “Nuggets.” You can see where this was going.
I spied a woman across the aisle laughing. Others were peeking above their PDAs. I turned to all of them and projected in my best stage presence: “How many people here think my daughter should have a good dinner tonight?” Seven people raised their hands. “And how many think she should have candy?” I simultaneously watched my daughter’s face as I polled the audience on this second choice. No hands. “See, sweetheart, everyone thinks you should have a good dinner.” So you see, I do not shy away from public interaction.
“Where do you work?” is, on the surface, a natural and common question. Yet, this was personal enough to feel uncomfortable. I wasn’t prepared for it so early in the morning. And not when it was delivered by someone I didn’t know. This wasn’t an art opening. And without thinking, I lied. “At the IRS,” I stated as if I’d worked there for years and was already in the final stages of planning for my retirement. I’ve got to hand it to me, instinctively, I used my best repellent. I didn’t want to tell her where I worked. There was something about her.
But I regretted it immediately, for lying, yes, but even more, for the quality of my lie. I answered without thinking of the possible consequences. What if she worked at the IRS? What would I have done when she asked which department? She looked like she could work at the IRS. I pictured myself begging for forgiveness from someone I didn’t even know.
As our train moved downtown I watched to see if she got off before our transfer. Not a chance. Hmmph. We changed trains. She followed. But on the next platform she went the other way.
Relief. I’d dodged a bullet. But it still didn’t feel right. And this was not over. There would be other mornings. I had never pictured myself working at the IRS. With this knowledge, would she start querying me about the latest tax laws and her deductions? She seemed the type. Would I find myself digging an even bigger hole, having to tell her I worked in the audit department (the strongest repellent known to man)? Would this dissuade someone who felt no compunction asking a stranger WHERE THEY WORKED at this hour?
I was awake. And I ruminated for at least an hour after I got to my office cube. I had created an unexpected persona for myself. My daughter’s father was a tax auditor at the Internal Revenue Service.
How does an auditor act when commuting? I pictured myself wearing Sansabelt™ slacks, a short sleeve white shirt with broad blue vertical stripes (too wide to be subtle), and a necktie with the Rugrats on it. My federal ID was on a long chain around my neck and neatly tucked into my shirt pocket (pocket protector and pens optional). I had given myself this part. It wasn’t something I had consciously aspired to but the role was mine. Did I have the talent to pull this off? What would I do the next time I saw her?
I didn’t have to wait long. Two days later, as we marched up to the Metro turnstile I saw her waiting for the elevator. This time I took the initiative. “How are you this morning?” She scowled. “I’m angry.” My heart dived. Had she found me out? She pulled a letter out of a folder and handed it to me to read.
It was from her supervisor advising her of her unsatisfactory performance review. My instincts had been correct. She had few boundaries. What could I say? I was so amazed that a total stranger would share her personal and personnel facts that I could only gloss over the details on the paper in my hands. I scanned while I decided quickly how to respond. My daughter was bouncing around me while we waited for the elevator door to open.
“I’m sorry.” I neither wanted to say more nor anything that might prolong the conversation. I truly was sorry. I knew how tough office relationships can be. All of a sudden, I was no longer worrying about my IRS status. The tables had turned as I held my invitation to be part of her morning drama. My daughter and I walked to our seats as the station lights dimmed.
nina
Posted at 10:54h, 21 MayOnce again, Jeff, I am reminded of how you described your father. But more than that “closed-off-ness”, I am concerned about your kids hearing you lie and subsequently learning to lie, which I don’t believe you mentioned.
I realize each situation has to be a judgement call and I agree that teaching the girls not to talk to strangers (as well as other guidelines) is important, but I do think you acted overly concerned with privacy by lying about your job — I don’t want to think that way about people. I do agree with the way you handled the woman with no boundaries — have run into that myself.
As for the man who wanted her name, I’ve found that repeating myself (sometimes ad nauseum) works for me. As in “I’m sorry, we’re teaching her not to talk to strangers”. “What’s her name?” “I’m sorry, we’re teaching her not to talk to strangers”.
I know hindsight is always 20/20….
Love,
me
I feel like I can be totally open and honest w you. More like a critique than a criticism.
Jeff
Posted at 12:00h, 21 MayNina, I hope it came across that I didn’t like lying in retrospect, both conceptually and, quite honestly, in the ramifications of having to live that lie. I don’t think my daughter, who was preoccupied with other things, heard me. But I could equally hear her say “YOU WORK AT THE SMITHSONIAN!” So, I dodged another potentially embarrassing and lethal parental bullet.
Something that I tried to get across in this story is that I often feel, when I’m in a public place with my children, that I have to think very quickly on my feet. Part of this is just the normal parent-child interaction. Little people can, with major abandon and impulsiveness, trek out on their own in any direction that suits their fancy.
In addition, being a parent often means becoming a mother hen. I’ve grown to be naturally protective. While children are approachable, in a world where adults must be guarded, they also have the same rights to privacy that us older folk do. I have had well-meaning people stoop down and touch my children without their or my permission. They have as much right to their personal space as we do.
Children start with the assumption that people are all good and safe. Wouldn’t it be great if that were true? Until it is or until my children can develop the same filters that most of us have learned, it’s my job to make sure they are safe. Understandably, that often means I am saying things to strangers I wouldn’t ordinarily say. I’d rather err on the side of safety than not.
My children have learned to not talk to strangers. This, of course, starts as a black and white rule (when we all know life is full of shades of gray). But as it sinks in, they begin to bring up all sorts of qualifiers. That’s where it becomes very gratifying to be a parent. Teaching your child to learn the rules and then to question them is close to my soul. Watching them make sense of it makes the difficult times worthwhile.
Chesh
Posted at 03:54h, 23 MayIRS isn’t completely a lie, if you simply change a few letters around, it’s almost an acronym of where you work…
I guess I never learned shades of grey: my mom’s friend used to tell a story about a time I had gone to stay with her at her beach house. We were walking along the beach, and we ran into a friend of hers. Apparently I was being taciturn, as my host asked me why I wouldn’t say hi to her friend. I whispered to her that I wasn’t allowed to talk to strangers. “But he’s not a stranger, he’s my friend,” she said. I was skeptical.
meryl
Posted at 09:47h, 24 MayI rode the metro many times and I can’t honestly recall if I ever talked to a stranger. Sad, eh? Growing up in Texas, we all smile and say, “Hi” to one another. In DC, when I attempted to do that… the other person looked at me like I was from another planet.
It’s so hard. After all, all my friends were strangers at one point. But, of course, I met them at school or organizations. I don’t think I’ve ever made a friend with someone I met on a bus or metro or airplane. Actually, I did exchange information with a nice person I met on an airplane, but we never followed up with each other.
Thanks for the breakfast food for thought.
Jeff
Posted at 10:39h, 24 MayMeryl, believe it or not, my daughter and I HAVE made friends on the subway. There’s Barry who works at the Pentagon and Gayle, who (ironically, considering the lie I told) works at the IRS!
Each relationship developed slowly. Barry, for example, would come up to me when I had neither of my children and ask if they were ok. We got to talking a little and it went from there. We often see Gayle when we get off the train in the morning (it’s very interesting how people’s schedules are often so in sync).
Just like any other relationship you “feel” each other out, getting a sense of who they are and things move from there. Like other relationships, the parameter of these friendships are set by mutual consent. Gayle and I don’t know each other’s last names nor where we live. We’ve never asked each other. My daughter and I love to see Gayle in the morning and, from Gayle’s face, the feeling is mutual.
There’s something wonderful to be said for a friendship of this nature.
Chris Abraham
Posted at 10:54h, 13 JuneThis post reminds me a lot of the writings of Milan Kundera. I believe that — amongst other things — you would be an excellent Novelist or Columnist — depending on whether you wanted to swallow the blue or the red pill.